At a glance
- Four Indian granite quarries were assessed at 16%, 18%, 26% and 21% block recovery, as estimated recoverable volume over mapped rock volume1.
- Three modelled grids on one Botticino marble bench gave maxima of 49.1%, 33.3% and 47.5% of modelled bench volume2.
- The EU Ecolabel ratio is (B + C) ÷ A, blocks plus by-products sold over material extracted, in m³ over 12 months; it must be at least 0.506.
- In the sources we reviewed, we found no published block recovery figure for Greek marble quarries.
Why the figures are hard to compare
A quarry can quote several block recovery figures for the same extraction period; a 2016 trade article gave the example of an owner who quotes 40%, of which only part is sold as dimensional blocks9. Before any figure can be compared, it needs three things stated: what is counted as output, what it is divided by, and whether both are physical volumes, masses or invoiced (commercial) volumes.
Invoiced volume is an accounting quantity. Under EN 1467:2022, a block's commercial size refers to its gross or net size, excludes recognised defects and may include a general reduction for trade, usually net dimensions minus 0.05 m17. The stone left out by that reduction is not waste; it leaves the quarry inside the block. A ratio built on commercial volume therefore does not describe a physical material balance (see how a quarry block is measured).
Three numbers that are all called recovery
1. Block recovery. In this article: the physical quantity of blocks produced divided by the physical quantity of rock extracted, in m³/m³ or t/t. Each study computes its own version; the two whose definitions we read divide modelled or estimated usable block volume by modelled or mapped rock volume1,2.
2. The EU Ecolabel extraction efficiency ratio. The EU Ecolabel criteria for hard covering products (Commission Decision (EU) 2021/476, criterion 2.2) ask the quarry operator to declare five quantities, in m³, for the most recent calendar year or a rolling 12-month period6:
- A: total quantity of material extracted;
- B: saleable blocks produced from A;
- C: extractive waste and by-products (block fragments, stones and fines) that are sold;
- D: the same materials used internally for useful purposes, or stored in the by-products deposition area;
- E: extractive waste sent to the waste deposition area or landfill, plus by-products stored there.
The ratio is printed in the Decision as an equation image, which reads: extraction efficiency ratio = (B + C) ÷ A6. Material used on site or stored as by-products (D) is declared but does not enter the ratio. "For calculation purposes, it should be assumed that A-B = C+D+E", and data in tonnes are converted to m³ "using a fixed bulk density factor for the rock material being extracted"6. "The extraction efficiency ratio shall be at least 0,50", and up to 25 points are awarded on a scale from 0.50 to the "environmental excellence threshold of 1,00"6. The Commission's Joint Research Centre explains that crediting by-products sold, "the B+C" approach, avoids penalising quarries that produce both blocks and crushed material7. Its background report says that for a block quarry "a typical extraction efficiency would be 0,20 to 0,40", and that slate can be as low as 0.037; that is a background estimate, not a set of measured quarries. Because the ratio adds by-products sold, it can exceed block-only recovery; with no by-products sold, the two are equal. In one Italian case, the authors evaluate a Botticino quarry whose waste all serves as raw material for on-site cement production at a recovery ratio of 1.00, while its modelled block recovery was 33.3–49.1%2; the paper does not say how that material would be entered in the Ecolabel streams, and under the Decision material used on site (D) does not count towards (B + C) ÷ A.
3. Quarry-to-product yield. The share of extracted rock finally sold as slabs, tiles or other products, after the losses in the plant. Figures from Montani's world stone statistics published in 2021, as cited in a 2023 peer-reviewed paper, put this at 91.5 million of 318 million tonnes of gross quarrying, or 29% by mass4. Montani's report is private; we read only the citation.
What the studies report
The rows below are on different bases and are not a league table. "Modelled" means computed from fracture data or cutting software; none of the rows is a series of annual production records.
| Study: stone, place | Published; data year | Method and scale | Reported figure | Numerator ÷ denominator | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Granite, four quarries, India | 2016; case studies from earlier work, year not stated | Estimate from joint and defect mapping | 16%, 18%, 26%, 21% overall (abstract); the first case table gives 17.21% | Estimated recoverable volume ÷ theoretical volume of mapped natural blocks, m³/m³ | 1 |
| Marble, one bench, Botticino, Italy | 2025; not stated | GPR fracture survey and cutting software, three grids | Maxima of 49.1%, 33.3%, 47.5% (one per grid) | Total usable block volume ÷ modelled bench volume, m³/m³ | 2 |
| Limestone quarry, Italy | 2021; not stated | Cutting optimisation; scale not stated in abstract | Highest obtainable 53% | Not stated in the abstract | 3 |
| Dimension stone, Tan Long, Binh Dinh, Vietnam | 2023; not stated | Joint-set and cutting-grid model (abstract only) | Highest 13.87% | Not stated in the abstract | 5 |
| Marble, Estremoz anticline, Portugal | 2022; not stated | Research summary (grey literature) | About 9% marketed | Marketed ÷ "picked material"; mass or volume not stated | 12 |
| World, all dimension stone | 2023; Montani data published 2021 | Industry statistics (Montani), cited secondarily | 49% sent on to processing; 29% marketed as product | Tonnes ÷ tonnes of gross quarrying | 4 |
The EU Ecolabel background estimate of 0.20–0.40 for block quarries7 is a different ratio, (B + C) ÷ A, and is kept out of the table for that reason.
The panels are not comparable with each other: each uses its own basis.
1 · Modelled or mapped block recovery, % of rock volume (m³/m³)
2 · Model results, basis not stated in abstract
3 · Marketed share of picked material, basis not stated
4 · World mass flows, % of gross quarrying (t/t), Montani data published 2021
5 · EU Ecolabel ratio (B + C) ÷ A, background estimate
Further cautions:
- Wide literature ranges are passed on without data. The Indian paper tabulates earlier ranges of 5–15%, 10–12%, 30%, 7–97% and 22–85%1, and a 2025 review states a range of 3% to 60%11. We could not trace these to primary measurements, so they are not in the table or the chart.
- Recovery also splits by grade. In the Indian study, the recovered block output of the first quarry was split into grade A 12%, B 32%, C 38% and D 19%1. These are shares of recovered output, not of extracted rock; the reported rounded shares sum to 101%.
- Technique ranges, secondary. The JRC report cites a study of marble quarries in North Macedonia (Dambov et al., 2013) in which extraction efficiency ran from 0 to 2.5% with drilling, blasting and cutting, 2.5–10% with diamond wire saw and cutting machine, 10–40% with a cutting machine, and above 40% with cutting machines "in situ"7. We did not open the original, so its denominator and the comparability of the sites are not known to us.
What drives recovery
Fractures first. The 2023 paper that cites Montani names the geological conditions of the deposit, "including discontinuities and fractures in the rock mass", as the main factor in quarry waste4. Research on raising recovery combines fracture mapping, such as ground-penetrating radar, with cutting-pattern software2,4.
Extraction method. The JRC comparison, drawn from a 2018 study, rates waste generation lower for diamond-wire cutting than for blasting or plug-and-feather splitting7; the figures cited here do not establish a recovery improvement that holds at every site.
Target block size. Target block dimensions affect both recovery and economics. In the cited limestone model, the lowest production cost occurred at the lowest-recovery block size3. On the Botticino bench, modelled recovery fell slightly as block volume grew2. The block plan that maximises recovery is not automatically the one that maximises profit.
What happens to the rest
Montani's figures published in 2021, as cited, put quarry waste at about 163 million tonnes, 51% by mass of 318 million tonnes of gross quarrying4. In the Carrara basin, a 2017 study counted about 80 million m³ of waste in old dumps and about 3 million m³ added each year8; the JRC, citing the same group, reports that only about 0.5 million m³ a year is sold or converted into secondary raw materials7. A 2024 review states that "more than half of the extracted marble remains as quarry waste or debris" at Carrara10. Around Afyon in Turkey, quarries were reported in 2012 to produce about 270,000 tonnes of marble waste pieces a year14; a mass figure, not comparable with the Carrara volumes.
The JRC lists uses from monoliths and roadside barriers to aggregate, fill and fine powder for agglomerated stone7. Selling those materials raises a quarry's Ecolabel ratio through C6; it does not change its block recovery.
The further loss in the plant
A block that leaves the quarry loses more stone in sawing, trimming and breakage. Across 19 processing plants in Bilecik, Turkey, which produce about 11% of Turkey's marble, waste was 28% in block cutting and 20% in gang sawing; the abstract converts these to 756 kg and 540 kg of waste per m³ of stone processed13. These are two different operations, not successive losses on one block. A 2021 review puts processing waste at 10–35% of the stone processed, with the volume of sludge up to three times that of solid scraps15. Montani's figures, as cited, put processing waste at 63.5 million tonnes, about 41% by mass of the 155 million tonnes entering plants worldwide, in data published in 20214.
Part of the loss is fixed by the saw. In 2006, machine makers quoted gang-saw kerfs of 6.5 mm, 7 mm and 8.5–9 mm, and one multi-wire maker a kerf (bead diameter) of 7 mm (trade press)16. Example, arithmetic only: with a constant 7 mm kerf repeated between equal slabs, each 2 cm slab plus its cut spans 27 mm, so cuts take 7 ÷ 27 = 25.9% of that repeat; for 3 cm slabs, 7 ÷ 37 = 18.9%. End cuts, trimming and the cut count for a particular block are left out.
Example using a hypothetical 22% bench recovery and an assumed 20% sawing loss, for arithmetic illustration only, with both on the same physical basis: 0.22 × 0.80 = 17.6% of the extracted rock reaches the sawn-slab stage, before any trimming or polishing loss.
How a quarry can measure its own block recovery
The method below is our recommendation, not a requirement of the Ecolabel or of any standard. It keeps one physical basis, mass in tonnes, for the material balance, and reports invoiced volume separately.
- Input (A), in tonnes. Survey the bench before and after the period (drone, total station or laser scan) to get the in-situ volume extracted, and multiply by the measured apparent density of the rock.
- Block output (B), in tonnes. Weigh every block produced from that bench in the period, whether sold or held in stock. Physical block volume, if needed, is mass ÷ apparent density.
- Other streams, in tonnes. By-products sold (C), material used on site or stored in the by-products area (D) and waste to the dump (E), weighed or surveyed. Check that A − B = C + D + E6; a large gap means a stream is not being measured.
- Ratios. Block recovery = B ÷ A. Ecolabel-type ratio = (B + C) ÷ A6; converting every stream with the same fixed factor, as the Decision does, leaves this ratio unchanged.
- Invoiced output, separately. Report the commercial volume invoiced for the same blocks, with its size convention, as a sales figure. Do not put it into the balance.
- Per bench and per period, noting extraction method, target block size and the grade split of B.
Example with stated assumptions: a bench survey shows 1,200 m³ of rock extracted in one month; measured apparent density 2.70 t/m³, so A = 3,240 t. Blocks produced weigh 820 t (B). By-products sold: 500 t (C). Used on site for ramps: 160 t (D). Waste to the dump, from the balance: 1,760 t (E); weighing it would close the check instead of assuming it.
- Block recovery: 820 ÷ 3,240 = 25.3%.
- Ecolabel-type ratio: (820 + 500) ÷ 3,240 = 40.7%. Adding D would give 45.7%, but D is not in the Decision's ratio.
- Invoiced output, reported separately: the same blocks were sold as 264 m³ of commercial volume, against 820 ÷ 2.70 = 303.7 m³ of physical volume. 264 m³ is 22.0% of the 1,200 m³ surveyed, a sales ratio, not a recovery figure.
What the literature does not tell us
- Greek marble. In the sources we reviewed, we found no published block recovery figure for marble quarries in Drama, Kavala, Thassos or elsewhere in Greece. Searches in Greek returned licensing decisions and theses without such numbers.
- Measured, multi-year recovery from production records: we found none in the studies reviewed; the figures above are modelled, estimated or sector statistics1,2,3,4,5.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a typical block recovery rate in a marble or granite quarry?
The studies we found do not support one typical figure. Four Indian granite quarries were assessed at 16–26% of mapped rock volume1, while models reached grid maxima of 33.3–49.1% on a Botticino marble bench2 and 53% in an Italian limestone quarry3. These cannot be combined with marketed-material shares, such as about 9% at Estremoz12, or with mass-based world statistics4 as a single benchmark.
What is the EU Ecolabel extraction efficiency ratio?
It is a criterion of the EU Ecolabel for hard covering products, not a general legal duty. The quarry declares material extracted (A), saleable blocks (B), by-products sold (C), material used on site (D) and waste (E), in m³ over 12 months6. The ratio is (B + C) ÷ A; it must be at least 0.50 and earns up to 25 points at 1.006.
How much stone is lost when blocks are sawn into slabs?
In 19 Turkish plants, waste was 28% in block cutting and 20% in gang sawing, or 756 and 540 kg per m³ of stone processed, for those two operations13. A 2021 review gives 10–35% of the stone processed15. With a constant 7 mm kerf, cuts take about 26% of each repeated 2 cm slab-and-cut span (arithmetic example).
Why do recovery figures differ so much between studies?
Is there published data on recovery in Greek marble quarries?
We did not find any. In the open literature and the Greek-language searches we ran, we found no measured or modelled block recovery figure for Greek marble quarries. Searches returned licensing decisions and theses that do not report such numbers.
How Noria Strata handles this
Noria Strata gives every block an ID from the moment it comes out of the face, and records blocks and cubic metres per face, every day, in one balance with the yard, the factory and sales. A drone flight shows the quarry in 3D, with what came out of each face and what is left in the yard, month by month. Those are the records a recovery figure is built from. See extraction and quarry management.
Sources
- Rajan Babu, A., Naveen, G. C. & Meena, S. S. (2016). A novel grading methodology and recovery assessment technique for dimensional stone production. Proceedings of RARE 2016, Atlantis Press download.atlantis-press.com/article/25864917.pdf
- Reed, K. M. & Bonduà, S. (2025). Production optimisation and environmental protection in ornamental stone quarries using ground penetrating radar techniques. Revista Minelor – Mining Revue 31(3): 93–103. DOI 10.2478/minrv-2025-0032 upet.ro/miningrevue/Vol_31_2025/Issue_3/09%20Reed%20M%20-%2010.2478_minrv-2025-0032.pdf
- Şirin, E., Bonduà, S. & Elkarmoty, M. (2021). Environmental and economic optimization for block cutting of dimension stones in a limestone quarry. Resources Policy 74: 102396. DOI 10.1016/j.resourpol.2021.102396 (abstract) ideas.repec.org/a/eee/jrpoli/v74y2021ics0301420721004050.html
- Jalalian, M. H., Bagherpour, R. & Khoshouei, M. (2023). Environmentally sustainable mining in quarries to reduce waste production and loss of resources using the developed optimization algorithm. Scientific Reports 13: 22183. DOI 10.1038/s41598-023-49633-w (citing Montani, 2021) ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC10719332/fullTextXML
- Pham, V. V., Nguyen, A. T., Pham, V. H. & Tran, D. B. (2023). Dimension-stone quarrying optimization through integrated modelling between joint sets and cutting grid: a case study at Tan Long dimension stone quarry in Binh Dinh. Inżynieria Mineralna 1(2). DOI 10.29227/IM-2023-02-37 (abstract) inz-min.online/index.php/im/article/view/559
- European Commission (2021). Commission Decision (EU) 2021/476 of 16 March 2021 establishing the EU Ecolabel criteria for hard covering products. OJ L 99, 22.3.2021, criterion 2.2 (p. L 99/53) susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/product-bureau/sites/default/files/2021-04/Decision_2021-476_EUEL_HCP.pdf
- Donatello, S., Garbarino, E., Sanfelix, J., Fernandez Carretero, A. & Wolf, O. (2021). EU Ecolabel criteria for hard covering products. Final Technical Report: criteria and supporting rationale. European Commission, Joint Research Centre susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/product-bureau/sites/default/files/2021-04/Final_TR_PUBSY-submit-x.pdf
- Dino, G. A., Chiappino, C., Rossetti, P. & Baccioli, G. (2017). Extractive waste management: a new territorial and industrial approach in Carrara quarry basin. Italian Journal of Engineering Geology and Environment, Special Issue Marmotec 2016: 47–55. DOI 10.4408/IJEGE.2017-02.S-05 rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa02/engineering_geology_environment/article/view/1197
- Litos (2016). Recovery rate in quarries. LITOS no. 128 (trade press, no author named) litosonline.com/en/article/recovery-rate-quarries
- Tazzini, A., Gambino, F., Casale, M. & Dino, G. A. (2024). Managing marble quarry waste: opportunities and challenges for circular economy implementation. Sustainability 16(7): 3056. DOI 10.3390/su16073056 (abstract) ideas.repec.org/a/gam/jsusta/v16y2024i7p3056-d1371084.html
- Madear, C. & Madear, G. (2025). Minimisation of waste, water and energy consumption at extraction of dimension stone to support eco-label certification. Revista Minelor – Mining Revue 31(2): 84–91. DOI 10.2478/minrv-2025-0021 reference-global.com/download/article/10.2478/minrv-2025-0021.pdf
- Talento, K. & Amado, M. (2022). The metamorphosis of the landscape: the dynamic reuse of marble waste. CERIS Technical & Scientific Activities Report, IST Lisbon (grey literature) ceris.pt/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/2022_RG5_Miguel-Amado-Katia-Talento.pdf
- Yurdakul, M. (2020). Natural stone waste generation from the perspective of natural stone processing plants: an industrial-scale case study in the province of Bilecik, Turkey. Journal of Cleaner Production 276: 123339. DOI 10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.123339 (repository abstract) acikkaynak.bilecik.edu.tr/items/b6e42353-16d0-46fa-8f2a-c826b3295151/full
- Çelik, M. Y. & Tur, Ş. (2012). Afyonkarahisar Organize Sanayi Bölgesi Doğal Taş Atık Depolama Sahasındaki Mermer Atıklarının Özelliklerinin İncelenmesi. AKÜ Fen Bilimleri Dergisi 12: 9–15 dergipark.org.tr/download/article-file/18425
- Strzałkowski, P. (2021). Characteristics of waste generated in dimension stone processing. Energies 14(21): 7232. DOI 10.3390/en14217232 doi.org/10.3390/en14217232
- Daniel, P. (2006). Multi-wire saws gains ground. Stone Business, 6 December 2006 (trade press) stonebusiness.us/?p=416
- CEN (2022). EN 1467:2022 Natural stone – Rough blocks – Requirements. Preview pages of SIST EN 1467:2022, clauses 3.2–3.4 and 4.1.1 cdn.standards.iteh.ai/samples/72591/b25b7404e3cb4139b24cb91ca3cfd48c/SIST-EN-1467-2022.pdf
How to cite this article
Konstantinou, M. (2026). Block recovery in dimension stone quarries: what the studies report. Noria Strata. https://www.noriastrata.com/en/blog/block-recovery-dimension-stone-quarries
The author
Maria KonstantinouCTO, Noria Strata
